The Book Whisperer

jottings, musings and recommendations of an incurable bookaholic

Book Review: Special Topics in Calamity Physics by Marisha Pessl January 23, 2010

Filed under: Marsha Pessl — The Book Whisperer @ 1:00 pm
                                                                                  What Goodread says: “Special Topics in Calamity Physics is a darkly hilarious coming-of-age novel and a richly plotted suspense tale told through the distinctive voice of its heroine, Blue van Meer. After a childhood moving from one academic outpost to another with her father (a man prone to aphorisms and meteoric affairs), Blue is clever, deadpan, and possessed of a vast lexicon of literary, political, philosophical, and scientific knowledge—and is quite the cineaste to boot. In her final year of high school at the elite (and unusual) St. Gallway School in Stockton, North Carolina, Blue falls in with a charismatic group of friends and their captivating teacher, Hannah Schneider. But when the drowning of one of Hannah’s friends and the shocking death of Hannah herself lead to a confluence of mysteries, Blue is left to make sense of it all with only her gimlet-eyed instincts and cultural references to guide—or misguide—her.

Structured around a syllabus for a Great Works of Literature class and containing ironic visual aids (drawn by the author), Pessl’s debut novel is complex yet compelling, erudite yet accessible. It combines the suspense of Hitchcock, the self-parody of Dave Eggers, and the storytelling gifts of Donna Tartt with a dazzling intelligence and wit entirely Pessl’s own.”

 

What I thought: Really? Darkly hillarious? Richly plotted? I attempted to read his book several years ago but due to the fact that I keep coming across reviews for it,  I now feel compelled to warn potenital readers of how utterly appalling I found it. Were we even reading the same book?
I actually picked this off the shelf in eager anticipation while hunting for some holiday reads. Being a massive Donna Tartt fan, the blurb comparing the two grabbed me hook, line and sinker and the book didn’t even get as far as my suitcase – that’s how keen I was to start this.
After the first 100 pages I decided that life is far too short. To summarise: there is little or no plot that I could fathom, the characters were all hideous (give me someone to love or hate, but not someone who I couldn’t care less about and certainly not 10 of them), the writing was way OTT even for an American teenager (Dawsons Creek eat your heart out).  

I read alot of books (as you know) but I can’t remember the last time something irritated me as much as this one. The blurb is misleading – in no way is this anywhere near as good as The Secret History. If you haven’t already read Donna Tartt’s TSH, then I implore you buy that instead. And if you get a taste for murder on an American campus then get Paulina Simon’s Red Leaves. Both are a thousand times better:

 

 

 

 
Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 3,457 other followers